Judge Panel
Build completion loop
Product Strategy4.5/5
CARRIED, unchanged, human-gated: AC-VAL-001..005 blocked — the business-value thesis is unvalidated by any real buyer (value-evidence.md status blocked, approver none, every measurement not performed); the…
Full verdict
- CARRIED, unchanged, human-gated: AC-VAL-001..005 blocked — the business-value thesis is unvalidated by any real buyer (value-evidence.md status blocked, approver none, every measurement not performed); the design_interiors op, the durable AC-AI-001 fallback, and the completed multifamily margin are technically real, yet no external buyer has confirmed time saved or trust earned. Fix: one qualified design-partner session against docs/release-plan.md §2/§9, then populate value-evidence.md with real data and a human approver.
- ROTATED from the closed Feasibility merged item: SFD solver typology breadth (GB-0701) still cannot serve a real infill parcel — the SMALL_PARCEL_MULTIFAMILY_SUGGESTED advisory narrows it honestly (additive, never perturbs geometry/yield/score) but no new residential typology engine landed; the SFR solver still yields ~5 lots vs ~36 real units on the Reno 2.0-acre parcel whose real use is garden apartments (multifamily_bar v1 only). Fix: advance GB-0701 beyond multifamily_bar v1 (garden/stacked/townhome infill engines), or explicitly rescope the SFD wedge to plat-scale greenfield in the ICP doc; consider a dock action carrying the advisory into a multifamily re-solve.
Real Estate Feasibility4.6/5
No active P1 risk.
Production Homebuilding4.5/5
NEW (merges a Strategy flag): the credited multifamily hard-cost closure lands SURFACE-DISHONEST — feasibility-cockpit.mjs:374 lifts only construction.totalCents (dropping basis/basisNote/source, asymmetric with the…
Full verdict
- NEW (merges a Strategy flag): the credited multifamily hard-cost closure lands SURFACE-DISHONEST — feasibility-cockpit.mjs:374 lifts only construction.totalCents (dropping basis/basisNote/source, asymmetric with the Land row which carries landBasis) and cockpit-dock-model.mjs:1088 hardcodes the Construction row note to 'Hard construction from the configured mix', which is affirmatively false for a modeled scheme: a real 48-unit scheme prices a $10.85M leg from builtAreaSqft x the $210/sf national-benchmark default while the dock caption claims a configured-mix source and silently drops the override/excludes caveat. Payload honest and redaction-safe; only the render layer flattens the caveat. Fix: thread construction.basis/basisNote through money.constructionBasis exactly as landBasis is carried and render the modeled-basis note when basis starts with 'modeled'; add a dock test asserting the note reflects the modeled basis.
Architecture/API/Data4.5/5
NEW (the drift class ROTATED a second time, route axis -> data axis): the Postgres carriage contract silently drops >=10 flow-written top-level state collections (deal shares and markups, feasibility studies, AI-render…
Full verdict
- NEW (the drift class ROTATED a second time, route axis -> data axis): the Postgres carriage contract silently drops >=10 flow-written top-level state collections (deal shares and markups, feasibility studies, AI-render provenance, the project dossier, prompt-contract amendments, and the agent learning/skill/notification/mistake ledgers) — absent from REQUIRED_POSTGRES_STATE_TABLES and all migrations 0001-0017 — with no state-key orphan guard, a 5-collection roundtripCounts verifier, and a census test whose title overclaims completeness it does not verify. JSON local state stays authoritative so no data is lost today, which keeps this P1 not P0. Fix: a state-carriage orphan guard analogous to the §5.6 route guard (walk state.<key> writes, assert carried-or-allowlisted with per-key reasons), then migrations + presence-exact carriage for the persistent collections; retitle or derive the census test.
UX/Product Surface4.7/5
No active P1 risk.
Brand System4.5/5
No active P1 risk.
QA/Security4.6/5
No active P1 risk.
Delivery/Backlog4.5/5
No active P1 risk.
Current implementation verdict: conditional pass · P0 0 · P1 4